Inside Four Shadows, at the corner of Main and Mill streets in Wauconda, there is an old photograph of James F. Carr at work in the ice cream shop he opened in that building in 1935. The stamped metal ceiling is original. So is the Main Street cafe sign. The newest part of the room is a garage-door window that opens onto the sidewalk, and it is the reason the bar opened later than planned.
"We thought we'd have this place open in May," owner Rob Dalton told the Daily Herald. "We were held up a little with the garage door and things beyond my control." The bar opened June 25, 2026, in time for Wauconda Fest. That ended four years of vacancy in a Civil War-era building that has sold general merchandise, furniture, dry goods, ice cream and sweets, and has been a restaurant for roughly the past 50 years. For anyone in North Barrington looking for somewhere new to go out this fall, the nearest answers are on one short stretch of South Main Street. All three are in buildings much older than anything around them.
Three Doors Within a Few Steps of Each Other
The three newest places on Wauconda's Main Street sit almost on top of each other. Each one lives inside a building's history instead of replacing it.
The Grand Social House & Tavern, 110 S. Main St. The name comes from Elliott's Grand Hotel, which the restaurant describes as a cornerstone of early Wauconda hospitality. The restaurant says the building holds "nearly 200 years of stories" in its beams and floorboards. The menu is homestyle Italian comfort food with handcrafted cocktails. Greg and Alexandra Walsh are partners, with chef Chris Blackburn and sommelier Phil Castello on the team. A February 18, 2026, WhatNow report described it as recently opened, though no exact opening date has been published. The Grand takes limited reservations and keeps a waitlist, and the OneTen Club Lounge offers a second room for drinks after dinner.
Cellar 109, 109 S. Main St. Across the street is a speakeasy-style lounge from co-owners Lauren Cunliffe, Kayla Baggett and Michelle Sarrafi. Before opening, it was presented as a space for ticketed events and private rentals, serving Prohibition-era cocktails and small bites, with a ribbon cutting announced for March 5. Today it works more like a regular bar. The current schedule lists open lounge hours most Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays from 6 to 11 p.m., and ticketed Cellar Sessions still run separately.
Four Shadows, 120–122 S. Main St. Dalton and a partner have run the original Four Shadows at Ashland Avenue and West Diversey Parkway in Chicago for 15 years. Friends from that bar persuaded him to look at Wauconda. One of them, Todd Probasco, is a Wauconda Area Chamber of Commerce member. As in the city, Guinness is the signature pour, and the menu covers fresh, never-frozen burgers, wings, chicken wraps and freshly made deli sandwiches at lunch.
The Roof Came Before the Menu
The Four Shadows space was not empty for four years because nobody wanted a restaurant there. Bulldogs grill ran in that spot for 12 years before closing on July 31, 2022, due to the pandemic. Village Administrator Allison Matson pointed to a less visible problem. When foot traffic drops, old buildings still carry large maintenance bills, and a landlord has a hard time leasing a space with a failing roof or worn-out mechanicals.
So the village built incentive packages around those repairs, acting on resident input to fill the restaurant vacancies on Main Street. The amounts were small:
| Building | Repair | Total cost | Village share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Former Bulldogs, 120–122 S. Main | HVAC replacement | $25,000 | $20,000 reimbursed |
| Former Bulldogs, 120–122 S. Main | Facade grant | $15,000 available | $12,500 for garage door, sign and repairs |
| The Grand, 110 S. Main | Roof replacement | $40,000 | $20,000 |
The Grand also has a $15,000 facade grant available, but that money had not been spent as of the July 2026 report.
"These small investments by the village helped the owners to get the buildings ready to be leased and helped preserve the Main Street we treasure." — Allison Matson, Wauconda Village Administrator, to the Daily Herald
The garage door that held up Dalton's opening was partly paid for by that facade grant. Fixing the building came first, and the restaurant followed.
What an Empty Lot Overlooking Lake Zurich Revealed
A few miles away, Lake Zurich spent the same stretch of time on the opposite kind of site. Block A, at 173 W. Main St., is 1.7 acres of village-owned land made up of 10 consolidated parcels, directly across from the promenade on the lake. In September 2025 the village board gave preliminary approvals to The Waterfront Lake Zurich. That plan, from Deerfield-based THG Holdings, called for a two-story building for a restaurant and 19 townhouses. Over more than 20 years the site had drawn steady interest but no project.
In August 2026 the board voted unanimously to end the sale. The engineering behind this plan went further than any earlier concept for the site. Assistant Village Manager Michael Duebner said it showed that soil remediation and extensive drainage and stormwater measures made a commercial building there not economically viable. "It's a lesson in what really goes on with a piece of property," he said. Under the termination agreement, the village will pay $415,000 in entitlement costs and keep THG's feasibility studies and plans for future use. The village says it is not discussing a sale or entertaining other offers, and the board will decide what happens next.
Lake Zurich's newest small dining success came from an old building. CHIC Cafe & Crepes opened in mid-August 2025 at 8 N. Old Rand Road, in a renovated former shoe-repair shop. The village sold that building to True North Properties in March 2024, and it was renovated for commercial tenants. Owners Adriana and Dan Latcu serve sweet and savory crepes, panini, gelato, coffee, tea and lemonade. In both towns, the places that opened over the past year did so where a building already stood and needed repairs. The open lot by the water still has no project.
The Rest of Main Street Around the New Arrivals
The three newcomers joined a downtown that already had places to eat and drink. The Village of Wauconda's downtown guide points to Honey Hill Coffee Co., Whisk Bakery & Coffee Shop and Lots-a-Knots Italian Bakery. Honey Hill is at 107 S. Main, steps from Cellar 109. Whisk is at 216 S. Main, and Lots-a-Knots is at 106 N. Main. A few blocks north, SLYCE Coal-Fired Pizza is at 127 N. Main. Just off Main, Lindy's Landing at 115 Park Street is celebrating 60 years and offers dine-in and carryout. The Side Lot, a neighborhood pub at 110 Slocum Lake Road, posts its hours and takes online orders.
On a weekend, you could get coffee at Honey Hill in the morning and stop at Whisk or Lots-a-Knots for something to take home. Dinner could be shared plates at The Grand, and Cellar 109 is open later across the street on most Thursday through Saturday nights. Four Shadows suits a game-day afternoon, with the garage door open while the weather holds.
On the Calendar Through December
Downtown Wauconda's fall and holiday events use these same storefronts and sidewalks:
- Through October 15: Community voting for Wauconda Park District's Scarecrow in the Park.
- October 5 to 28: Voting for the Park District's Halloween House Decorating Contest.
- Thursday, October 15, 5 to 8 p.m.: The Wauconda Area Chamber of Commerce Fall Wine Walk on Main Street, billed as a chance to shop, sip and explore local businesses.
- October 25: Trick or Treat on Main Street. The Chamber has not posted hours yet.
- Wednesday, November 25: Holiday Lights on Main at Village Hall, 101 N. Main, with free admission and complimentary coffee and hot chocolate.
- Saturday, December 5: Holly Jolly Holiday at the Park District Community Center, 600 N. Main, with a local vendor market, carolers at 4:45 p.m. and a tree lighting with Santa at 5 p.m.
The Park District's outdoor Farmers' Market closed for the season on October 1. That leaves the Wine Walk as the next big evening on Main Street, and the first fall for all three new places to take part.
Wauconda's Main Street revival started with a new roof and a working HVAC system, long before anyone saw a menu. Older homes work the same way. In our experience, buyers respond to what a home has been through and what has been taken care of. If you're weighing which repairs and finishes to tackle before you sell, Tara Kelleher and our in-house staging team can walk through your home with you. Get your home valuation and staging plan.