Under North Barrington's current zoning code, a house that doesn't meet today's setback or district rules can be maintained and repaired. It cannot be expanded. If it is destroyed beyond half its replacement cost, it has to be rebuilt to current standards. For a buyer, that means the addition sketched on the back of a showing sheet may be off the table on day one.
The village's public draft code, dated July 2026, would rewrite that rule. The draft's bans on short-term rentals, accessory dwelling units, and data centers are getting the attention. But compare the draft with the code in force today, and most of the change for owners sits in a chapter few people will read: the one on nonconforming homes.
What an older house can and can't do right now
A "nonconforming" structure is one that was legal when it was built but no longer meets current rules. One example is a house that sits closer to a side lot line than the current setback allows. Chapter 4 of the current North Barrington zoning regulations lets that kind of building continue. It may not be "expanded or enlarged." If it is destroyed past 50 percent of its replacement cost, it can't be re-established unless it conforms. Maintenance and minor repairs are allowed as long as they don't expand the structure.
Those two rules shape a deal. A buyer can't plan a second-story addition or a kitchen bump-out on a nonconforming house the way they would on a conforming one. A seller can't fairly market the house as having room to grow. A major casualty loss also raises a practical question: whether the house could go back on its original footprint at all.
What the July 2026 draft would change
Section 14.3 of the public draft code treats single-family and two-family homes differently from other nonconforming buildings. If a nonconforming home is damaged or destroyed by an act of God, it may be rebuilt to its original condition "regardless of the percent of damage." A building permit application has to be filed within one year, and that deadline can be extended for good reason. Nonresidential, townhouse, and multifamily structures keep a 50 percent threshold.
The second change is about expansion. If a house is nonconforming because it extends into a required rear or interior side setback, the draft lets it be enlarged horizontally or vertically "along the same plane as the existing perimeter walls," as long as the result doesn't break any other district rule. Eaves already inside the side setback can stay but can't extend any farther.
| Question | Current code | July 2026 draft |
|---|---|---|
| Can a nonconforming home be enlarged? | No | Yes, along existing wall lines, when the nonconformity is a rear or interior side setback encroachment |
| Rebuild after major damage | Must conform if destroyed beyond 50% of replacement cost | Act-of-God loss may be rebuilt to original condition at any damage level, with a permit application within one year |
| Short-term rental threshold | Less than 93 consecutive days, with limited exceptions | 30 consecutive days or less, no exceptions listed |
| Accessory dwelling units | No general allowance | Prohibited village-wide |
| Front-yard fences | Barred except horse containment in R-1 | Up to 36 inches if open wrought iron, aluminum or split rail |
The expansion rule is narrow. It covers rear and interior side setbacks only, and it requires the new work to stay on the line of walls that already exist. Still, a house that today can only be maintained would be one that could be added onto.
Why the rental and ADU bans move less than they appear to
The short-term rental prohibition sounds new. The current code already bans it. In the R-1, R-2, and R-3 districts, rentals to non-relatives for less than 93 consecutive days are prohibited, with three exceptions. A seller may rent the home back after a sale. A resident who has sold their home may rent a different one. Any other owner may rent for under 93 days with a Village Administrator permit and a $50 fee, after showing that the rental isn't mainly for parties or gatherings of more than ten people.
Section 7.1 of the draft prohibits both offering and using a short-term rental, and it defines one as a rental of "30 consecutive days or less" to anyone outside the owner's immediate family. Two things change. The permit route disappears from the text. And the definition no longer reaches stays of 31 to 92 days. A stay in that range would still be subject to the draft's use matrix and its rule that any use not listed is prohibited, so the shorter definition alone doesn't make those rentals allowed.
The ADU ban follows the same pattern. The draft defines an ADU as "an additional dwelling unit associated with and incidental to a principal dwelling on the same lot." The draft defines a dwelling unit as having complete independent living facilities, so the ban appears to apply to a guest house or coach house that functions as a separate dwelling, whatever it is called. The current code doesn't generally allow those units either. Its residential use lists cover single-family residences and accessory structures, and ordinary accessory structures such as sheds, garden houses, and playhouses are capped at 250 square feet and 15 feet.
There is one exception that would actually be affected. The Premier Equestrian Estate District currently allows separate quarters of up to 1,500 square feet for no more than two adult domestic employees. If a unit like that meets the draft's ADU definition, a village-wide prohibition would remove that allowance. For anyone buying or selling an equestrian estate, that is the line to read closely.
Statewide, two 2026 Senate bills would have required Illinois municipalities to allow ADUs. SB 4071 was introduced February 24, 2026, and was last referred to Senate Assignments. SB 3726 was re-referred to Assignments on April 24, 2026. Neither has been enacted, so no state mandate currently overrides a village ADU prohibition.
The smaller rules that shape a project plan
Most of the rest of the draft is about the projects owners take on after closing. It replaces general language with specific numbers:
- Fences. Today, front-yard fences are barred except for horse containment in R-1, other fences are capped at 42 inches, and fences must be at least 50 percent open. The draft would allow front- and corner-side-yard fences up to 36 inches if they are open wrought iron, aluminum, or split rail. Fences in other yards could be 48 inches, animal fences 60 inches, pool fences 48 to 60 inches, and sports-court fences up to 12 feet.
- Solar. The current code allows panels integrated into a roof or wall, or ground arrays fully shielded from neighbors and streets. The draft would allow roof panels up to 18 inches above a pitched roof or 4 feet above a flat one. Freestanding systems would go in the rear yard only, with a 20-foot cap.
- Exterior lighting. Light at the lot line would be limited to 0.5 footcandle next to residential property and 1.0 footcandle next to a street or nonresidential use. Freestanding fixtures could be no taller than 15 feet and would have to be full cutoff. Projects that require a lighting plan would need public-area lighting at a color temperature of 3,200K or below.
- Pools. Above-ground pools would be prohibited. Hot tubs could still use a qualifying safety cover in place of a fence.
- Hens and larger animals. The limit of six hens on lots of 40,000 square feet or more stays the same, and coops could also go in interior side yards outside the setback. In R-1, lots of at least three acres could keep three animals per five acres, up to six, housed at least 200 feet from a neighbor's dwelling.
The fence change is the one a buyer will notice from the street. The rest mostly come up when a contractor is pulling permits.
Where the draft stands on the calendar
None of this is law yet. Here is how the process has gone so far, based on village records:
- July 2026. The public draft is released.
- August 17, 2026. The Plan Commission and Zoning Board of Appeals hold a joint workshop. Arista Strungys of Camiros, LLC presented the draft. According to the meeting minutes, Village Administrator John Lobaito asked that individual questions be emailed to him, and Building and Zoning Officer Kelly Rafferty said he was pleased with the format and agreed with the minor changes and their interpretations.
- September 14, 2026. The Plan Commission agenda lists a review and discussion of the July draft. This was not a public hearing.
- October 12, 2026. The Plan Commission meeting is listed as canceled.
- Next. A Plan Commission public hearing will be held on a date not yet announced, followed by a Village Board vote expected in late winter or early spring 2027. Written comments go to [email protected].
Until the board votes, the current code governs, so the 93-day rental rule and the ban on expanding nonconforming homes still apply to any contract written this fall. One caveat: the zoning title on the American Legal code host says it includes ordinances only through October 24, 2018. Any later amendment should be confirmed directly with the village.
Quick answers
Does the draft change anything about renting a home back to its seller after closing? The current code specifically allows a seller rent-back. The draft's text doesn't list that exception, and it prohibits rentals of 30 days or less. Anyone planning a short post-closing occupancy can ask the village how that would be handled.
Does the expansion rule help a house that sits too close to the front lot line? As written, no. The wall-extension provision covers encroachments into rear and interior side setbacks only.
Could the draft still change before adoption? Yes. The public hearing hasn't been held, and the Plan Commission's recommendation to the Village Board is still to come.
If you own a North Barrington home that was built before today's setbacks, the 2027 code could change what your house is allowed to become, and that changes how it should be priced and presented. Tara Kelleher can go through where your home stands under the current code and the draft. Get your home valuation and staging plan.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.